How willing should they be to share their raw data with their staunchest critics?

Subject:How willing should they be to share their raw data with their staunchest critics?
Date:Fri, 04 Dec 2009 22:37:51 -0600
SCIENCE AND SOCIETY:
Stolen E-mails Turn Up Heat on Climate Change Rhetoric
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/short/326/5958/1329


Eli Kintisch
The theft and unauthorized release last month of 1000 private e-mail mess=
ages from the=20
servers of the Climatic Research Unit (CRU) at the University of East Ang=
lia in the United=20
Kingdom has provided a glimpse into the fractious world of climate scienc=
e. The public=20
airing of frank conversations among powerful scientists about sensitive t=
opics such as=20
possible holes in their data and the use of contrarian papers in major re=
ports comes at a=20
pivotal time for climate science, just days before a meeting of world lea=
ders in=20
Copenhagen. The messages=E2=80=94whether hacked or released by a disgrunt=
led insider=E2=80=94have raised=20
thorny questions about the proper behavior of researchers who feel under =
siege for their=20
science. How willing should they be to share their raw data with their st=
aunchest critics?

Read the Full Text
http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/326/5958/1329



Other posts:
i dedanoe want my grandfather's Pandovina back
Quantum Gravity 347.1: An Anti-Planck "Anti-Anthropic" Principle and Taiwan Advances GR Thermodynamics
design a crucible scoop shovel #36 Earth's Energy Future
Quantum Gravity 347.0: Italy Relates Symmetries of a Quantum System to Geometry, Algebra, and Analysis (Latter includes Probability!)
ripples? in 2.71K blackbody cosmic microwave radiation #193 Atom Totality theory
• How willing should they be to share their raw data with their staunchest critics?
Quantum Gravity 346.9: India on Temperature and Elasticity as Geometry (continued)
The Certainty Principle
God is mad
who is auditing the CRU code?
at the age of 33 Jesus was not crucified on the cross but he was then married for Maria Magdalena

generated at 01:08:16