How would you rule

Subject:How would you rule
Date:Wed, 3 Feb 2010 17:36:34 -0700
NS is an establiced parnership with more than 12,000 MP between them.
The bidding went
S E N W
1nt 2D* 2H** P
2Sp P 3nt P
P P

* alerted shows diamonds and a higher ranking suit
** 2 Hearts was alerted as a transfer to Spades.

NS do not play transfer in this sequence, and there were no correction
before the opening lead, N had not heard the transfer announcement. NS made
3nt. With a Spade lead they loose the first 5 tricks. E had K, 10, x, x of
spades.





Other posts:
XYZ invitational sequences
Difficult auction
Natural 55 2-suiters as 2-bids
Pusillanimous?
How much diamonds?
• How would you rule
Bidding with 9 hearts
Some painfully bad bidding.
Blasting to 3N with 4333
Annoyed again
Beat this 3NT contract

generated at 18:17:27